Now that's fine. And good. And I too want to support traditional marriage. But when I started putting together a table of other issues that I think are important, the groups I should support perform very poorly.
Issue\Party | LNP | ALP | Grn | CDP |
---|---|---|---|---|
Marriage | ? | X | X | ✓ |
Environment | X | ✓? | ✓ | X |
Tax | X | ✓ | ✓ | X |
Treaty | X | ? | ✓ | X |
Welfare | X | ✓ | ✓ | X |
Value early & late life |
✓ | X | X | ✓ |
Anti-Corruption | X | X | ✓ | ? |
NBN | X | ✓ | ✓ | ? |
Refugees | X | X | ✓ | X |
You might note I've tried to be positive here - I've said pro-marriage rather than anti-SSM, and I've said value early and late life rather than anti-abortion and euthanasia.
Several things stand out to me:
- The major parties are in bed with the big end of town. Big coal employ many ex LNP and ALP politicians and staffers. And as ex-PM Tony Abbott admitted what everyone already knew last week, there is give and take. As for the smaller Christian parties, they aren't in the same position, but they haven't made a stand against corruption by opposing votes which clearly benefit big coal.
- Aboriginal issues have not been well thought through. Recognition is the only one that gets a mention, which LNP and ALP have jumped on, although this is not what many Aboriginals want. A retrospective treaty with the first inhabitants has been shown to be the one thing that would give rise to a new relationship and give hope in a way that the Recognise campaign never could. The way in which the 'intervention' was carried out is one example to show that a new way of relating is required. *since initially publishing, Bill Shorten mentioned he would be in favour of looking at a treaty.
- As a follower of Jesus I believe caring for the most vulnerable is our duty. Doubly so when we are a wealthy nation. So a generous welfare policy and a thoughtful approach to tax are evidence of this.
- Lib and Lab are virtually indistinguishable on Refugee policy. There are subtle nuances, and from talking to my local MP I understand the complexity is far greater than a simplistic answer. I am slightly more sympathetic to ALP on the possibility of a humane policy, but I'm yet to hear from either of the duopoly a commitment to treat refugees as human beings.
- Lastly, the profligate approach to the environment since the infamous Rudd back-down and the reckless prejudicing of big coal's interests by the LNP are a massive indictment on our governments.
- As a late addition--NBN anyone?
Are there any others I should include on the list?
Any idea on how to weight and tally the results?
LNP = Liberal and National Party coalition
ALP = Australian Labor Party
Grn = The Greens
CDP = Christian Democratic Party
LNP = Liberal and National Party coalition
ALP = Australian Labor Party
Grn = The Greens
CDP = Christian Democratic Party
1 comment:
Yes a very tricky issue,
I'd add compassion through foreign aid.
This makes it very difficult to vote well and I am sometimes prone to single issue voting- God help us!
Post a Comment